Is HR Confidential?
2 minute read
The conservative and ever-annoying answer is: it depends. Generally speaking, yes, HR conversations should be confidential. However, it's crucial to understand the boundaries of confidentiality and ensure both parties are clear before delving into a discussion. While HR professionals should always strive to maintain confidentiality, there may be legal or organizational requirements that necessitate disclosure in certain situations, such as investigations or compliance issues. A good HR professional will outline upfront what they can keep confidential and what they can’t.
For instance, I once had an employee approach me frustrated with their manager. Upon hearing their concerns, it became evident that the manager was not following company policies, jeopardizing an important program. Despite the employee not explicitly asking me to take action, due to the severity of the compliance issues, I had to intervene. I assured the employee that I would address the matter directly with the manager while keeping their identity confidential. We discussed my approach, ensuring the employee was comfortable with the process.
Conversely, another employee approached me frustrated with a leader’s behavior in meetings. They described how the leader made irrelevant comments about their short tenure in the field, making them feel undermined and disrespected. I asked an important question, “Are you asking me for advice, or are you submitting a formal complaint?” In other words, do you want to handle this yourself or do you want me to handle it on your behalf? They were adamant to manage it themselves, seeking guidance on how to navigate this difficult situation. Given the importance of the issue, we agreed that if they couldn’t resolve the issue independently in a timely manner, they would return with more information for me to address it on their behalf.
A good HR professional will safeguard information shared with them. However, if the matter involves harassment, safety concerns, policy breaches, or impacts others, HR may be obliged to take action. If unsure, always begin conversations with a question about confidentiality to ensure mutual understanding.
Have questions about confidentiality? Let us help!
